Oligonucleotide Therapeutics Companies Crowding into GalNAc-Conjugation

Following Alnylam’s achievement of making subcutaneous administration work for RNAi gene knockdown in the liver by conjugating RNAi triggers to the GalNAc sugar, antisense companies have started to copy the approach.  As RNAi Therapeutics have made great progress in targeted delivery, antisense companies are starting to realize that in order to stay competitive and improve the safety of systemic uses of antisense, they need to get away from the notion of 'naked'/unformulated delivery that relies on swamping the body with phosphorothioated oligonucleotides.

This has become apparent at the AsiaTIDES meeting here in Tokyo where both Santaris and ISIS Pharmaceuticals disclosed their great interests in GalNAc conjugation.

In collaboration with Axolabs (the part of Roche RNAi Therapeutics that was not acquired by Arrowhead Research and that had familiarity with GalNAcs), Santaris presented phosphorothioate-LNA Factor VII (liver) knockdown data showing 80% gene knockdowns in mice following a single dose of 0.1mg/kg.  Even more potent knockdowns were seen at 0.25mg/kg and above. 

In another presentation by ISIS Pharmaceuticals on their cardiovascular franchise, the company noted that they will follow up on their initial Apo(A) (‘little A’) candidate with a GalNAc-conjugated version.  With this, they expect to increase potency by up to 10-fold, thus allowing for 10-30mg (~0.15-0.45mg/kg) dosing.

This illustrates the utility of the GalNAc receptor (ASGPR) and how the competing RNAi and antisense technologies are fertilizing each other.

Regulus Therapeutics, of course, is the first antisense (anti-miR) company of sorts that has adopted GalNAc conjugation for their liver-directed programs, most notably anti-miR122 for HCV that is about to enter clinical development.  Regulus obviously has a license to GalNAc from Alnylam.  Whether this also applies to ISIS Pharmaceuticals, remains to be seen.  The word on the lab floors is that GalNAcs per se are not patent-protected, so ISIS may use an entirely different linker strategy to Alnylam just as Arrowhead Research does with its GalNAc-targeted DPCs.

What it means for Tekmira and Marina Biotech

Since some of you are following my investment strategy, here is what I think this means for the liver-directed efforts by Tekmira and Marina Biotech (both of which I own). 

Marina Biotech could obviously follow the same path as ISIS Pharmaceuticals and Santaris in adopting GalNAc conjugation with its CRN technology.  As such, there should be no change in the competitive value of CRN compared to Santaris and ISIS antisense.  It could also attach GalNAcs to their liposome-based SMARTICLES for which delivery to the liver remains to be demonstrated.  To do all this, however, Marina Biotech needs to grow and establish in-house R&D.  

For Tekmira, it means that RNaseH antisense are getting close in potency for gene knockdown compared to the 2^nd gen MC3 SNALP LNPs (85-90% TTR gene knockdown in humans at 0.3mg/kg).  With the 3-fold more potent 3^rd generation SNALP LNPs which should enter the clinic this or early next year (TKM-ALDH2, TKM-HBV), Tekmira should stay well ahead of its competition with the most potent gene knockdown technology for the liver.  This means more addressable diseases and in most cases higher treatment effects as well.   And if it incorporated GalNAc-conjugated lipids into their liposomes, too, maybe that would extend that lead even further.

If gene knockdown in the liver is not a great example for why you need a competitive free market economy, then I don’t know what is. And, of course, there is no better example of why you need a lab ;).